I had a mitral valve repair two years ago today and am thankful for a wonderful recovery since then.
I'm wondering if anyone else in the valve surgery community ...Read more
I had a mitral valve repair two years ago today and am thankful for a wonderful recovery since then.
I'm wondering if anyone else in the valve surgery community has experience with this situation. About four months after surgery, I experienced a rapid heartbeat during cardiac rehab (my final session). I was diagnosed with atypical atrial flutter (meaning its on the left side of my heart).
I was put on Tikosyn, which I still take. In 20 months, I have had one episode of high heart rate, which resolved on its own within an hour. I see an EP every 6 months now and he says I'm doing fine, that the Tikosyn is working. My question is whether it's Tikosyn or whether my rhythm and rate would be OK on their own. In other words, was the episode that triggered this and landed me on Tikosyn, just an artifact of my surgery four months prior. Would I be doing just as well without medication?
Does anyone know of scientific research finding that such episodes happen after surgery and are one-time events? Is the Tikosyn overly aggressive?
Good luck to all those on the right side of this page awaiting their surgery. You've got this!
Susan Lynn Richard - Congratulations on your second anniversary! Wow! That time flew by. You pose an excellen ... Read more
Susan Lynn Richard - Congratulations on your second anniversary! Wow! That time flew by. You pose an excellent question about medication and isolated incidents. I would see if your physician is willing to slowly reduce your dosage to see if you need to continue and if you can be removed from it completely. However, I am not well versed enough to know how dangerous another episode of atrial flutter might be. I might also consider seeking multiple opinions if this is the only course of treatment your cardiologist is recommending. I realize that pharmaceuticals have their place, but I don't think it hurts to inquire. Good luck! Please keep us posted!
Marie Myers I am guessing that the docs would be hesitant to take you off the Tikosyn because of the risk of retu ... Read more
Marie Myers I am guessing that the docs would be hesitant to take you off the Tikosyn because of the risk of returning to flutter and possibly a fib. Both arrhythmias can lead to clot formation and possible stroke risk. Is ablation a possibility for you? I am guessing that a successful ablation might get you off the Tikosyn. What does the electrophysiologist say about an ablation?
Barbara Wood Wondering if you're on a blood thinner...they might be more inclined to see how things go off it if y ... Read more
Barbara Wood Wondering if you're on a blood thinner...they might be more inclined to see how things go off it if you have that layer of protection? Let us know what your ep thinks...take care:)
Richard Buckley Thank you for the notes Susan and Marie, I do plan to get a second opinion as I want to see if a dif ... Read more
Richard Buckley Thank you for the notes Susan and Marie, I do plan to get a second opinion as I want to see if a different EP might think the first is over-reacting. I am not opposed to an ablation if that will help. My wife has had two of them and no longer takes Tikosyn. I am not on a blood thinner. My current EP says an ablation might be the tradeoff for going off Tikosyn. I'm just trying to see what the research might say about this. I appreciate your thoughts.
Today marks one year on the recovery side for me. Thanks to everyone on this board for providing so much inspiration. I had a mitral valve repair (mini thoracotomy). ...Read more
Today marks one year on the recovery side for me. Thanks to everyone on this board for providing so much inspiration. I had a mitral valve repair (mini thoracotomy). I’m feeling great and I’ve only had one brief setback in recovery. I experienced atrial flutter about 4.5 months after surgery—final scheduled day of cardiac rehab. It seems under control now and I’m on Tikosyn. I’m blessed to have enjoyed great support from my family and friends. It was a definite help to have this board and to have read Adam's book before going in. I love his advice to take the five intangibles to the hospital with you.
I think one year ago today was the longest of my life and most of it lost to memory. I know my wife and daughter were with me until I was rolled to surgery … a prep nurse was determined to remove my wedding ring, which she did … the line being placed in my neck … and being told to breathe through this mask.
Then through a heavy fog in the cardiac ICU my wife told me the surgeon, Dr. Ralph Damiano of Washington University Physicians, said it could not have gone better … my valve was repaired and doing well. I don’t know how many times I woke up to learn that only 20 or 30 minutes had elapsed. I was vaguely aware of visitors, daughter, son, son-in-law. I sensed activity outside the room … a lot of family members for a patient who, sadly, would not be leaving.
I hope to never have to live a post-surgery day again, but it’s all been great from there. I kept improving, passed my routine checks and am living a normal life. I didn’t have any symptoms of my valve leak before surgery and I’m feeling great post-surgery.
Rob Sparling Richard, thanks for the update and thanks for leading the way! Glad things are going well!
Susan Lynn Happy Anniversary! It is a bit of a blur when you look back on game day (I also have gaps in my mem ... Read more
Susan Lynn Happy Anniversary! It is a bit of a blur when you look back on game day (I also have gaps in my memory from my hospital stay), but the good news is that it's behind you. Glad to hear you're doing well! All the best - Wishing you many decades of anniversaries and good health! ❤
Today marks 9 months on the recovery side from mitral valve repair. I'm living a normal life, exercising regularly and don't have to think much about having ...Read more
Today marks 9 months on the recovery side from mitral valve repair. I'm living a normal life, exercising regularly and don't have to think much about having had the surgery. I've been very fortunate as I know many in the group have been. It's great not to have a leaking valve anymore. I've had only one small setback, one incidence of high heart rate diagnosed as atrial flutter. I'm on tikosyn for that but, with luck, maybe I will get off that later this year. Cardio checkup next month and electrophysiologist in September.
All the best to everyone facing heart valve surgery; I look forward to good progress reports from you.
It's the Ides of March already and I totally forgot that Wednesday, March 13, marked six months of recovery from MV repair surgery. I chalk it up to doing ...Read more
It's the Ides of March already and I totally forgot that Wednesday, March 13, marked six months of recovery from MV repair surgery. I chalk it up to doing well that I don't give it that much thought any longer. I have had a good recovery, going through rehab, getting back to work and living relatively normal. I exercise at a gym several days a week, walk or run outside some days and am waiting for warmer weather so I can ride my bike. I am blessed to have had a smooth recovery. My only hiccup was the end of January when I had some atrial flutter finishing a rehab session. Got me a trip to the ER and three days in a hospital to load tikosyn. I'm now on it twice a day. I've had a follow up with my newly acquired EP doctor, and everything seems to be going well. All the best to everyone on the board.
Rob Sparling Great to hear, Richard! Congrats! Forgetting can be so liberating, eh?
Anyone have this happen? Four months after mitral valve repair. Today was last day of cardiac rehab. Nurses stopped me a few minutes before end of treadmill ...Read more
Anyone have this happen? Four months after mitral valve repair. Today was last day of cardiac rehab. Nurses stopped me a few minutes before end of treadmill session as heart rate shot up to 200. Took me down to ER. Diagnosis is atrial flutter. So I'm started on tikosyn. I was doing great, no problems. This came out of the blue. I felt no symptoms.
Lisa Guinan Ugh-no. I’m three months out from mitral repair and halfway through rehab, I’ll be following yo ... Read more
Lisa Guinan Ugh-no. I’m three months out from mitral repair and halfway through rehab, I’ll be following your posts.
Rob Sparling Wow, Richard. Sorry to hear! Scary weird. Hope you see it settle down again and leave this stage b ... Read more
Rob Sparling Wow, Richard. Sorry to hear! Scary weird. Hope you see it settle down again and leave this stage behind.
Debbie Moriarty Thank goodness the nurse was on it!! Scary. Hopefully the meds get it under control!
Tracy Simmons Hi Richard. I had mitral valve repair and went through rehab as well. I didn't experience anything ... Read more
Tracy Simmons Hi Richard. I had mitral valve repair and went through rehab as well. I didn't experience anything like that, but am thankful that happened while you were being monitored by skilled and trained nurses. Best of luck.
Susan Lynn Richard - Sorry to hear your news. Hopefully, this flutter is temporary. That's why we wear monit ... Read more
Susan Lynn Richard - Sorry to hear your news. Hopefully, this flutter is temporary. That's why we wear monitors at rehab - the medical team is on top of every metric. Please keep us posted on your progress. Stay positive!
Richard Buckley Heart rate numbers are pretty normal today. It is boring sitting here waiting for a pill two times a ... Read more
Richard Buckley Heart rate numbers are pretty normal today. It is boring sitting here waiting for a pill two times a day, with an EKG two hours later. It feels so different from post op. Then you know your heart is recovering from a rough operation and you have to regain strength a little at a time. Still need to be positive but it's a different hurdle to clear.
Tracy Fallu The exact reason for all that are able- attend cardiac rehab.
I hope all is well today.
Kim Boardman Should you continue rehab to be monitored? Best wishes you are doing well.
My mitral valve repair was three months ago today. I'm feeling great and going through cardiac rehab three mornings a week. I graduated to using an elliptical ...Read more
My mitral valve repair was three months ago today. I'm feeling great and going through cardiac rehab three mornings a week. I graduated to using an elliptical this week! I hope to be cleared to start mixing in a little running as part of therapy soon. I've been back to work for two months. I have to say I've really only had one bad day, and that was the first 20 hours after surgery. I certainly wish I hadn't need the surgery but I'm glad it has worked out so well. The support in this group is great and I with the same luck I've had to everyone out there facing any type of valve surgery. Remember Adam's five intangibles: courage, trust, healthy thoughts, patience and love.
Dan Vechiola Great report Richard! I'm glad your recovery is going well. Keep trucking one day at a time!
John Morales Great to hear these stories my journey has just begun still need to meet the surgeon but hearing stor ... Read more
John Morales Great to hear these stories my journey has just begun still need to meet the surgeon but hearing stories like yours makes it a bit bettrr thanks for sharing
Rob Sparling Good to hear from you, Richard! Way to go! Glad to hear you are on the elliptical now. 👍
I'm not anxious to do it, but we have snow on the way to St. Louis, and the driveway will have to be cleared. I'm two months past mitral valve repair (thoracotomy). ...Read more
I'm not anxious to do it, but we have snow on the way to St. Louis, and the driveway will have to be cleared. I'm two months past mitral valve repair (thoracotomy). My cardiac rehab staff thinks snow shoveling is a no,no. Surgeon says I'm OK. My pre-surgery cath showed all my arteries were clear. Anyone have medical advice to share?
Susan Lynn I had a mini-t mitral valve repair and had a five pound lifting restriction for three months. I coul ... Read more
Susan Lynn I had a mini-t mitral valve repair and had a five pound lifting restriction for three months. I couldn't even use the vacuum cleaner, so I wouldn't even consider shoveling snow. I don't advise that you shovel during this winter at all since it's very strenuous and you're not fully recovered, yet. Plus, the nerves in your chest are regenerating - you may have numbness, pins and needles, and maybe some pain. Don't do anything to jeopardize your healing. Maybe one of your friends or neighbors will handle your shoveling. Hope so!
Rob Sparling Richard, the “Heart 411” book from Gillinov/Nissen I am still reading says no to snow shoveling. ... Read more
Rob Sparling Richard, the “Heart 411” book from Gillinov/Nissen I am still reading says no to snow shoveling. Use it as an excuse to buy a snow blower! 😜. Heart strong and snow strong are two different kinds of strong, apparently. ( ❤️💪. ) < > ( ❄️💪)
Rob Sparling Thank you! I learned my emoji language skills from Jill (💩) and Jennifer John (💙💚).
My advice: DON'T DO IT!
Shoveling snow is EXTREMELY strenuous on the heart and you are just eight we ... Read more
My advice: DON'T DO IT!
Shoveling snow is EXTREMELY strenuous on the heart and you are just eight weeks out from the trauma of heart surgery. I would think it is way too soon to put that kind of a workload on your heart.
Richard Buckley Thanks for the advice. We did get the snow but the temperature got above freezing so most of the dri ... Read more
Richard Buckley Thanks for the advice. We did get the snow but the temperature got above freezing so most of the driveway cleared itself. No need to worry about it. We have a shortage of tween and teen boys in the neighborhood so I will have to figure something for the next snow.
Today marks eight weeks since my mitral valve repair (thoracotomy) at Barnes Hospital. I'm pleased with how well it has been going. I've just started my "official" ...Read more
Today marks eight weeks since my mitral valve repair (thoracotomy) at Barnes Hospital. I'm pleased with how well it has been going. I've just started my "official" cardiac rehab and I think it is less strenuous than the walking I was doing on my own before the rehab was prescribed. I'm back to work. The only real issue I'm facing is the continued nerve discomfort in my rib cage. I'm told that is common and will go away. If you are just preparing for surgery or your recovery is in its early days, know that it will get better. The 24 hours after surgery were no picnic for me but it's done nothing but get better for me. I know that's the case for others in our community. We're pulling for you. Keep on tickin'.
Rob Sparling Richard, awesome to hear from you and that things continue to improve! Way to go! 👍
Dan Baltazor Glad to hear things are better for you!!!
Dan Vechiola Great report Richard. I had the same never pain in the chest area. Mine seemed to go away at 6 week ... Read more
Dan Vechiola Great report Richard. I had the same never pain in the chest area. Mine seemed to go away at 6 weeks so hopefully your is about to go away as well. Keep grinding every day!
For those of you who are in cardiac rehab or have competed it .... what expectations should a newbie have? I'm scheduled to start in early November, which will ...Read more
For those of you who are in cardiac rehab or have competed it .... what expectations should a newbie have? I'm scheduled to start in early November, which will be nearly 2 months after my surgery (mitral valve repair). Before surgery I had no symptoms and maintained a pretty active exercise schedule. I ran 2-3 miles a couple days a week and rode a bike one day. Post surgery, I"m up to about 40 to 45 minutes walking a day, divided between two outings. Should I expect they would help me return to a slow run pace over time in rehab? I'm happy to have the supervision but if their goals for me are limited, the rehab may not benefit me. I'm no super athlete but I have been active.
Susan Lynn They'll start you slowly, but will pretty much let you exert yourself provided your heart rate and b ... Read more
Susan Lynn They'll start you slowly, but will pretty much let you exert yourself provided your heart rate and bp stay within acceptable limits. You'll be wearing a heart monitor and will have your bp taken during exercise. I was pretty surprised that my blood pressure was pretty high after surgery during rehab. It has become more consistent over time, but I had some concerning intermittent results. Play it by ear, Richard. Everyone is different.
Rob Sparling Richard, thanks for asking the question and Susan thanks for the answer! I will be starting my CR on ... Read more
Rob Sparling Richard, thanks for asking the question and Susan thanks for the answer! I will be starting my CR on Nov 12th and am also very curious (and excited!).
Jennifer John Cardiac rehab is a must, guys. You’ll work slow and steady, at your own pace. Doesn’t matter what ... Read more
Jennifer John Cardiac rehab is a must, guys. You’ll work slow and steady, at your own pace. Doesn’t matter what others do. Tomorrow, I’m 5 months post-op and my 30th CR session is this Friday. Go as long as your insurance allows. And then keep going at an outside facility or at home. For more CR stories, see my Journal posts.💪🏼❤️
Louanna Miller Thanks for asking the question Richard. I am 8 weeks post OHS for MV repair. I start Cardiac Rehabi ... Read more
Louanna Miller Thanks for asking the question Richard. I am 8 weeks post OHS for MV repair. I start Cardiac Rehabilitation next Wednesday.
From everything I have read, it is very beneficial in recovery and regaining strength and endurance. It starts slow, but you can share whatbit is you want to be able to do upon completion. Seventeen years ago, my then 65 y/o daddy post quadruple bypass, shared in rehab that he wanted to be able to pick up 75 pounds with no problems. Cardiac Rehab worked with him and today at 83 he is still lifting 70 pounds on his farm.
I had my one-month checkup with my surgeon today. I had a right thoracotomy mitral valve repair on 9/13. The surgeon, Dr. Damiano of Washington University in ...Read more
I had my one-month checkup with my surgeon today. I had a right thoracotomy mitral valve repair on 9/13. The surgeon, Dr. Damiano of Washington University in St. Louis, was quite pleased. The incisions are not inflamed and are healing well. My heartbeat sounds strong. He no longer needs to see me and I am released to a cardiologist. I will be getting set up for cardiac rehab so can't wait to get going. I walk 40-45 minutes a day on my own and am doing stretches of my right shoulder to keep it loose from the incision below the armpit. I'm pleased it's going so well. For those who are awaiting surgery, know that many of us are happy to share our experience and pull for your success!
Eleven days after mitral valve repair:
I’ve now been home for one week and am feeling much stronger. I walk 5 or 6 times a day without getting breathless. ...Read more
Eleven days after mitral valve repair:
I’ve now been home for one week and am feeling much stronger. I walk 5 or 6 times a day without getting breathless. The only discomfort continues to be in my right groin incision and right shoulder, above my thoracotomy incision. I wrote last week that I really didn’t give much thought to my shoulder hurting. I have done the prescribed shoulder rotation exercises to prevent against frozen shoulder and those seem to be helping. I wrote a week ago that I feared I would have to essentially repeat a rehab process that took months following rotator cuff repair seven years ago. Thankfully, that doesn’t seem to be the case.
I went to my neighborhood’s annual block party yesterday afternoon. It was about 100 yards from our house, and fortunately I agreed with my wife’s suggestion that she drive us. The 100 yards is all uphill. It was great to be out with my neighbors, but 90 minutes was enough. I spent the time mostly sitting in a chair, which was on a slant. By 90 minutes, my groin became painful, so I headed home. Everything is fine this morning.
I feel like I have crossed the threshold of just being content to just sit and get better. I’m actively looking for things I can do (like write this), which don’t take a lot of physical effort. I may try tackling a few small work-related activities later in the week.
For those of you who are further along in your recoveries, thank you for sharing your stories and your encouragement. For those whose surgeries are more recent, have faith that improvement is happening. I’ve found that not every day is great, but the overall trend is upward.
MARIE PICUN Thanks for the update. Sounds like you are doing good. God bless
Dan Vechiola Great job Richard! I have found being social wears me out more than the 2 mile walks each day. Keep ... Read more
Dan Vechiola Great job Richard! I have found being social wears me out more than the 2 mile walks each day. Keep grinding and before you know it life will be back to normal.
Rob Sparling Richard, thanks for the update and the chronological waypoint!
Jennifer John You’re doing great, Richard. I also had an MV repair via right thoracotomy incision. The shoulder e ... Read more
Jennifer John You’re doing great, Richard. I also had an MV repair via right thoracotomy incision. The shoulder exercises work wonders. Keep on moving! Also, cardiac rehab was a big help in regaining strength.❤️💪🏻
Richard Buckley Thanks. I have to get through my surgeon follow-up on 10/16 and then will get into the rehab. Meanti ... Read more
Richard Buckley Thanks. I have to get through my surgeon follow-up on 10/16 and then will get into the rehab. Meantime,I use the exercises they gave me.
Groin pain.
Has anyone who had a thorocotomy been subject to pretty intense pain around groin incision. My surgery was one week ago today. Pain has kicked ...Read more
Groin pain.
Has anyone who had a thorocotomy been subject to pretty intense pain around groin incision. My surgery was one week ago today. Pain has kicked up late today.
Steve Farthing Thoracotomy - yes. But intense pain around that femoral artery incision a week later did not happen ... Read more
Steve Farthing Thoracotomy - yes. But intense pain around that femoral artery incision a week later did not happen to me. Maybe some pain, but not intense. Definitely worth a call back to your surgeon.
Jennifer McInerney I haven’t had one but that doesn’t sound right to me. Definitely requires a call to the Surgeon
Jennifer John Thoracotomy, yes, for my MV repair surgery. But that’s nowhere near your femoral artery. Was groin ... Read more
Jennifer John Thoracotomy, yes, for my MV repair surgery. But that’s nowhere near your femoral artery. Was groin incision for something else?
Steve Farthing FYI - They sometimes make an incision in the upper thigh into the femoral artery to connect the heart ... Read more
Steve Farthing FYI - They sometimes make an incision in the upper thigh into the femoral artery to connect the heart bypass pump when doing a non-sternotomy valve procedure.
This is something that hit me the last few days. I had a right thorocotomy to repair mitral valve last Thursday. Surgery went well as I posted testerday. BUT, ...Read more
This is something that hit me the last few days. I had a right thorocotomy to repair mitral valve last Thursday. Surgery went well as I posted testerday. BUT, it never dawned on me that cutting right below my armpit would affect my shoulder so much. It's fairly painful and I can't lift my arm much. I had rotator cuff surgery on the same shoulder 7 years ago and it took months to rehab it to get straight and ROM back again. So I've already started my exercises. Not saying I would have chosen sternum over thorcotomy, but I would have thought harder. Remember, it's not JUST about your heart.
Louanna Miller Thankful your surgery was successful!!! You are ahead of many using your exercises for your shoulder ... Read more
Louanna Miller Thankful your surgery was successful!!! You are ahead of many using your exercises for your shoulder.
Rita Savelis Hi Richard. I'm glad to hear you are doing well (and had a repair rather than replacement) but sorry ... Read more
Rita Savelis Hi Richard. I'm glad to hear you are doing well (and had a repair rather than replacement) but sorry to hear of your pain. It's still very early for you, so hopefully your arm movement will get easier soon. But you're right -it is not just about your heart. It's about your whole body! There can be repercussions everywhere. Take care.
Susan Lynn I had the right mini-t, but my surgeon placed my incision a bit lower to hide it. I think you'll see ... Read more
Susan Lynn I had the right mini-t, but my surgeon placed my incision a bit lower to hide it. I think you'll see tremendous improvement in the next few weeks. Good luck!
Jennifer John Richard, you’re one of a handful of us on this site who underwent a thoracotomy. It has been an int ... Read more
Jennifer John Richard, you’re one of a handful of us on this site who underwent a thoracotomy. It has been an interesting road. Pls see some of my past Journal posts, which may help you in recovery. I’m at 5-months post op today and am at about 90%. Takes time for those back and side chest muscles and nerves to heal.❤️👍🏻
I 'm finally up to posting. After a one-day delay, I had my mitral valve repaired on Thursday, 9/13. The surgeon, Dr. Ralph Damiano at Barnes-Jewish in St. ...Read more
I 'm finally up to posting. After a one-day delay, I had my mitral valve repaired on Thursday, 9/13. The surgeon, Dr. Ralph Damiano at Barnes-Jewish in St. Louis, told my wife it could not have gone better. I had no symptoms pre-surgery, but he saw some enlargement of left atrium, so it was time.
Was in ICU just under 24 hours, the longest time of my life. I had half a dozen bouts of dry nausea. Every time I woke up, I found only a half hour had passed. I was barely aware of family members being there for short visits. On a chest x-ray, they noticed a bubble in my stomach that may have contributed to nausea. I agreed to a nasal gastric tube to suction air out. Not fun but I was willing to try anything. PT helped me stand a few times and I survived that. About noon Friday I was moved from ICU to step down. Surgeon came by and pulled nasal tube. Graduated from ice chips to broth. Saturday they pulled chest drains, which had been a little painfu!. Have not much pain except for back. I was up walking the hall several times. That was tiring. But I felt good doing it. I had a good night of sleep last night, with Oxy as the pain pill. The standby pacer wires got pulled this morning so I should be on target for discharge tomorrow. It is amazing how much happens in a short time! Keep the faith of you are waiting.
Dan Vechiola Welcome to the recovery side Richard! The worst part is now in your rear view mirror. Take it one da ... Read more
Dan Vechiola Welcome to the recovery side Richard! The worst part is now in your rear view mirror. Take it one day at a time and keep positive thoughts.
Thomas Brusstar Great progress! Every tube or wire gone is progress.
Kathy Sansone Great news! I too measured my progress as each tube or wire I wasn't hooked up to! It helped me
Catie B Hope you continue to have a smooth, strong recovery!
Meredith Geneja An encouraging report, Richard. Thank you! Discharge soon....gotta love that. We will keep the fait ... Read more
Meredith Geneja An encouraging report, Richard. Thank you! Discharge soon....gotta love that. We will keep the faith for sure, thanks again for writing
Rob Sparling Great to hear from you, Richard! Good news. Great progress! Thanks for posting.
Dan Vechiola You'll do greqt Richard. I will echo what most others in this community have said about the surgery ... Read more
Dan Vechiola You'll do greqt Richard. I will echo what most others in this community have said about the surgery. Its definately not as bad as I thought it would be.
Waiting gets longer. After my cardiac cath, I was admitted. Soon after, Dr. Damiano came to my room and told me that a transplant emergency today messed up ...Read more
Waiting gets longer. After my cardiac cath, I was admitted. Soon after, Dr. Damiano came to my room and told me that a transplant emergency today messed up the OR schedule for tomorrow. I'm pushed back to Thursday morning. Oh well.
Mark Wilbur Sending best wishes for a successful outcome, Richard. Enjoy the extra day, if you can and know that ... Read more
Mark Wilbur Sending best wishes for a successful outcome, Richard. Enjoy the extra day, if you can and know that you'll be on the recovery side soon.
Jennifer McInerney Relax, take a deep breath. Try not to curse the scheduling Gods knowing that someone needed that OR ... Read more
Jennifer McInerney Relax, take a deep breath. Try not to curse the scheduling Gods knowing that someone needed that OR more than you. The wait is awful but worth the result. Hang in there. Your heart family is praying for you.
Richard Buckley Yes, someone got a transplant who probably needed it badly. Another day of waiting is a minor inconve ... Read more
Richard Buckley Yes, someone got a transplant who probably needed it badly. Another day of waiting is a minor inconvenience.
Dan Vechiola Hang in there Richard. I was pushed back a 1/2 day last Thursday for my surgery due to an emergency ... Read more
Dan Vechiola Hang in there Richard. I was pushed back a 1/2 day last Thursday for my surgery due to an emergency as well. Right now you are in middle of it all so stay cool and know that everything happens for a reason.
Catie B Delays due to emergencies happen a lot. Hope a bit more waiting isn't hard on you. All the best to yo ... Read more
Catie B Delays due to emergencies happen a lot. Hope a bit more waiting isn't hard on you. All the best to you Thursday and for a very strong recovery!
Only a few days to wait before surgery now. I go for a cardiac cath on Tuesday and will have the mitral valve repair (at least I'm expecting a repair) on Wednesday. ...Read more
Only a few days to wait before surgery now. I go for a cardiac cath on Tuesday and will have the mitral valve repair (at least I'm expecting a repair) on Wednesday. It's great to read the successes of people who had surgery this week, so see how well they are progressing. Very inspirational!
Nancy Luth Best wishes on a speedy recovery, Richard. I’ll be looking forward to your post op posts!
Rob Sparling Richard, enjoy yourself and keep positive! In a couple of days I will be wishing you a surgery that ... Read more
Rob Sparling Richard, enjoy yourself and keep positive! In a couple of days I will be wishing you a surgery that is right out of the playbook and a smooth recovery! Until then.
Dan Vechiola Think positive and visualize a successful surgery and hospital stay and distract dustract and distrac ... Read more
Dan Vechiola Think positive and visualize a successful surgery and hospital stay and distract dustract and distract your mind.
Rita Savelis Looking forward to Thursday then! Have a smooth ride.
Nancy LeClair Gottlieb Let us know how your doing. I'm having a Mitral Valve Repair on 9/24. Hope you have the best outcom ... Read more
Nancy LeClair Gottlieb Let us know how your doing. I'm having a Mitral Valve Repair on 9/24. Hope you have the best outcome and speedy recovery.
Dan Vechiola Visualize a successful surgery and hospital stay. Think positive and place your fate in the hands of ... Read more
Dan Vechiola Visualize a successful surgery and hospital stay. Think positive and place your fate in the hands of surgeon and hospital. Most importantly DISTRACT DISTRACT and DISTRACT your mind.
MARIE PICUN You got this. God has his hand on you. Prayers coming to you
I've been trying to research the merits of a tissue vs. mechanical mitral valve replacement, if I need it. I'm supposed too get a repair, but need the backup. ...Read more
I've been trying to research the merits of a tissue vs. mechanical mitral valve replacement, if I need it. I'm supposed too get a repair, but need the backup. I'm 65, which seems to be in thge gray area. What new info is there since Adam's book? Surgeon told me tissue valves are recommended at my age range. What other views are there?
Robert Bach Richard, I'm 66 years old and had mitral valve repair surgery on July 30. Surgeons asked me if I want ... Read more
Robert Bach Richard, I'm 66 years old and had mitral valve repair surgery on July 30. Surgeons asked me if I wanted a tissue or mechanical valve in case they couldn't do the repair, and I chose tissue as did two of my friends who had their valves replaced recently. My thinking was that I didn't want to take Coumadin the rest of my life, and my hope was that if/when they had to replace a tissue valve in 15 or so years, medical advancements would make it easier than it is today. I've heard others choose mechanical valves because they don't want to face another operation later in life. Repairs aren't 100% guaranteed to last, either. My surgeon, Dr. McCarthy, explained to me that mechanical valves are less popular now, though he didn't say why. I hope that helps.
Rita Savelis There is a good chance your valve can be repaired. But since you need a backup plan a tissue valve wo ... Read more
Rita Savelis There is a good chance your valve can be repaired. But since you need a backup plan a tissue valve would be recommended at your age as it should last longer in someone your age (over 60) than in a younger patient. But it is almost impossible to determine how long a valve might last in any specific body or heart - it could be from 8 yrs to 20 yrs, so you may need a replacement again (hopefully way down the line or not al all). TAVR valves (replacement through arteries) are not available for mitral valves, a more tricky valve to replace this way than the aortic valve. There are trends in medicine as in everything and the trend today is to reoperate (OHS is safe these days, so surgeons recommend re-surgery. ) I have 2 mechanical valves and living with anticoagulants is fine after a period of adjustment. In my case it was not advisable to reoperate as my valves and lungs have scarring from childhood cancer radiation, and OHS the first time was already difficult. Wishing you the best, and know that you are in the same boat as many patients and there really is no right answer to this choice of valve question. Your choice will work for you.
Thomas Brusstar My mitral valve regurgitation was severe, with at least one ruptured chord and a “flail” leaflet ... Read more
Thomas Brusstar My mitral valve regurgitation was severe, with at least one ruptured chord and a “flail” leaflet (basically a part of the valve flapping in the breeze down there), and my surgeon was able to repair, not replace. Pre-surgery he said 98% chance he could repair it, and he did. But he said he would use a bovine valve if absolutely necessary. He doesn’t recommend mechanical valves because of thinners and the cumulative stroke risk over many years. And he said if the cow ever wears out, it can be replaced going through an artery (I imagine groin?). So I mention that just because, contrary to what Rita heard, my surgeon said even today mitral cow valves can be revised trans-aterially.
So hopefully your non-severe regurgitation can be repaired rather than replaced, but my surgeon recommended a cow if we needed to get there.
Rita Savelis More info about TMVR:
TMVR is being done, but still in its early stages. Study results remain to be s ... Read more
Rita Savelis More info about TMVR:
TMVR is being done, but still in its early stages. Study results remain to be seen.
https://www.cardiovascularbusiness.com/topics/structural-congenital-heart-disease/proceeding-caution-will-transcatheter-mitral-valve
The cardiology community is paying close attention to developments related to transcatheter mitral valve replacement (TMVR) for mitral regurgitation. Although TMVR is in its infancy, one big question on everyone’s minds is whether its impact will be on the same scale as transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR).
Thomas Brusstar Interesting. I hope the transarterial route for primary mitral replacement advances. I understand r ... Read more
Thomas Brusstar Interesting. I hope the transarterial route for primary mitral replacement advances. I understand revising a tissue valve structure that is already in place is easier than placing the fake valve in the first surgery.
Mitral valve in valve is a minimally invasive transcatheter mitral valve replacement procedure for patients who have had previous open heart valve surgery. Learn more.
Richard Buckley Great perspectives on the choices. I had asked an NP in my surgeons office what info I could read bo ... Read more
Richard Buckley Great perspectives on the choices. I had asked an NP in my surgeons office what info I could read bout tissue and mechanical valves and she suggested "staying off the Internet." But do read patient reviews, which make sense. Thank you for providing those.
Thomas Brusstar Well, there are undoubtedly crazy sites on the internet (although I don’t think heart valve evaluat ... Read more
Thomas Brusstar Well, there are undoubtedly crazy sites on the internet (although I don’t think heart valve evaluation is a very ripe topic for wild conspiracy theories or ideological rants), and there is a lot out there; BUT this site is invaluable. It has substantive expert perspectives posted by Adam, and then tons of genuine experience (and encouragement to boot!). Learning enough to be an informed patient, and to ask the right questions, is the only way I could get my head around this deal. Tell your NP there’s at least one good site out there!
Michael Meyer Richard:
I chose tissue valve and that is also what my surgeon recommended and for many of the same r ... Read more
Michael Meyer Richard:
I chose tissue valve and that is also what my surgeon recommended and for many of the same reasons already cited.
Rita Savelis It's true that there are some crazy things on the internet. I have definitely seen patients who battl ... Read more
Rita Savelis It's true that there are some crazy things on the internet. I have definitely seen patients who battle it out. And companies marketing their valves... And even on this site in the past 3 years I have seen all out arguments about the merits of each type of valve, with patients writing that their choices are the only right ones rather than being open and stating how personal each choice is. There will always be pluses and minuses for each choice. And your heart problem is not the same as another's. There are many factors. So I am hoping you have a surgeon who is honest and shares valid information with you, but leaves the choice up to you. Ultimately I am hoping that you will be able to have a repair! Take care, Richard.
I'm new to this group and site as I have just been recommended for MVR and have read various posts and medical literature re: sternotomy vs. minimally invasive ...Read more
I'm new to this group and site as I have just been recommended for MVR and have read various posts and medical literature re: sternotomy vs. minimally invasive procedures. Does the side entry procedure really produce better recoveries, less pain, etc? I'd be interested in hearing various opinions. Have had two surgical opinions and they conflict!
Kathy Blank I had robotic MV Repair and found my recovery so incredible although you will need lots of rest and r ... Read more
Kathy Blank I had robotic MV Repair and found my recovery so incredible although you will need lots of rest and recovery for several months even minimally invasive is Open Heaet Surgery!
Kathy Blank Do lots of research and maybe one more surgical consult to help you determine what is best for you!
Chris Purvis Richard I’m not sure. Everyone will have their opinions on this just like mechanical vs. tissue val ... Read more
Chris Purvis Richard I’m not sure. Everyone will have their opinions on this just like mechanical vs. tissue valve. I had a Mini T under my right armpit to replace my BAV and Ascending aorta aneurysm. Pain was manageable from the beginning but I believe our friends with sternotomy will say the same. Maybe the only difference is restrictions go away quicker with the Mini T. I think either way the surgeons experience plays a vital part. You don’t one that hasn’t mastered the Mini T and on the flip side you don’t want one that is maybe complacent in the sternotomy due to lack of experience even wth this method. You want a surgeon that has done a lot of either procedure so that you can rest assure your getting quality.
Steve Farthing Had a mini-t done endoscopically for MVR and think that is a good option. They usually reverse the b ... Read more
Steve Farthing Had a mini-t done endoscopically for MVR and think that is a good option. They usually reverse the blood flow for a mini-t (retrograde perfusion) so you may need more pre-op imaging such as CT scan, echo, left.right heart cath, etc to make sure all vessels are clean enough to reverse the flow safely. But probably easier to lay flat in bed after the procedure, easier to get in/out of bed, smaller incision supposedly reduces infection risk, possibly drive sooner. And less intimidating to think about. If the doc knows how to do it, time on bypass pump should be same as regular sternotomy.
Carmel Robertson Didn’t know that about the minimally invasive approach Steve! So thanks. Richard, I had my MVR done ... Read more
Carmel Robertson Didn’t know that about the minimally invasive approach Steve! So thanks. Richard, I had my MVR done robotically and have very few incisions. I found the operation tough but the recovery was pretty fast overall. I had a very experienced surgeon so the operation was only 3 hours. So far, I have had an excellent result.
Susan Lynn I had a mini-t mitral valve repair. As Chris mentioned, finding a doctor who is experienced is key ... Read more
Susan Lynn I had a mini-t mitral valve repair. As Chris mentioned, finding a doctor who is experienced is key. I had a 3 day hospital stay, almost no pain (controlled with regular Tylenol), and an easy recovery. The result was excellent - that's the most important thing. Good luck with your research and decision.
Valerie Herndon-Vitarella I have had both. First I had the robotic with a 2 inch rt side incision and multiple port incisions. ... Read more
Valerie Herndon-Vitarella I have had both. First I had the robotic with a 2 inch rt side incision and multiple port incisions. A little more than a year and I found out the annuloplasty ring used in the repair was pulling apart from the valve. I then had a full sternotomy to re-repair (they don't go back robotically the 2nd time). Surgery on Monday & discharged Friday morning for both OHS. Pain was not bad for both approaches, but different; pretty much only took Tylenol since 2 days post op. I drove in 1 week for robotic & 4 weeks for sternotomy. Definitely there are more restrictions with sternotomy, but I went back to work 6 weeks after both. I would say, pick an experienced surgeon that has great outcomes and that you trust and do it either way the surgeon feels most confident of getting a good repair.
Elise Klein Hi Richard. I had a sternotomy about a month ago. I had my mitral valve and tricuspid valve repaire ... Read more
Elise Klein Hi Richard. I had a sternotomy about a month ago. I had my mitral valve and tricuspid valve repaired. My cardiologist said I could have minimally invasive, but the surgeon disagreed, saying the surgery was too intensive for minimally invasive. I'd go with the opinion of the surgeon who you choose to perform the surgery. For what it's worth, I'm feeling really good and returning to work next week (at the 6 week mark). Good luck!
Ellen Leng I had similar questions when I was recommended to have mitral valve repair 21 months ago. At that tim ... Read more
Ellen Leng I had similar questions when I was recommended to have mitral valve repair 21 months ago. At that time, there were quite a few stories on this site about post-op pain with the minimally invasive approach. As a right handed tennis player, I did not want to have long term issues. I talked at length to my surgeon, who did offer both options and elected a sternotomy. It is a mini-sternotomy, not complete, so that healing is probably a little less onerous than with a full sternotomy. I pretty much cannot tolerate narcotic pain medication and was on tylenol from post-op day 2 and forward :). I drove at 4 weeks, went back to work at 7 weeks (less related to the surgery and more related to post-op afib), did a sprint triathlon 6 months post-op, and have a great tennis serve! I have a chest scar which is below any low necked blouse I might wear, and I do recommend the mini-sternotomy approach.
I agree that you should talk to your surgeon about risks/benefits and their comfort level (or numbers per year) with either procedure.
Either way, your health will improve with the repair!
Best,
Ellen
Sophia Ridley Hi Richard, welcome!! I had full open surgery for MV repair in Nov 2018. I discussed options and for ... Read more
Sophia Ridley Hi Richard, welcome!! I had full open surgery for MV repair in Nov 2018. I discussed options and for my repair the surgeon was more confident of a successful repair through open (99% vs 90%). That was good enough for me as I don’t want to do this twice. I don’t regret it, I wear my scar with pride!
Bonnie Stone-Hope Hello Richard,
I had a full sternotomy for mitral valve repair.
No infection, quick healing, and mi ... Read more
Bonnie Stone-Hope Hello Richard,
I had a full sternotomy for mitral valve repair.
No infection, quick healing, and minimal pain (seriously!) Plus, my Mother had a full sternotomy in the same hospital 20 years previously so this procedure worked for me.
Vanessa Corwin I had the minimally invasive approach for my MVR; good recovery. The best advice my cardiologist gav ... Read more
Vanessa Corwin I had the minimally invasive approach for my MVR; good recovery. The best advice my cardiologist gave me was to pick a surgeon who is a valve specialist and discuss your options.
Tammy Seigel It is important to understand what your particular situation requires and look for the best possible ... Read more
Tammy Seigel It is important to understand what your particular situation requires and look for the best possible outcomes based on the doctors’ history.
I had what was called a “complicated” mitral valve with severe regurgitation. While I did have doctors tell me they could do the minimal invasive procedure, I opted for an approach through my sternum with a highly recommended doctor in a city where we had family (since we had to go out of town.)
Your confidence in the doctor and team who will help you heal is essential.
I’m in week 3 of recovery and so far so good! The sternotomy is definitely a challenging recovery, but I had heard the rib recovery could be painful as well.
Dan Marcantel Where do you want it done? My recovery went really well. I did have a couple problems. One being I a ... Read more
Dan Marcantel Where do you want it done? My recovery went really well. I did have a couple problems. One being I am now just finally getting the feeling back in my left pinky and ring finger. Mayo said this was normal that there was some nerve that may have been damaged but it would come back. It did finally. I was also told I'd only have a 2-inch scar but mine is more like 4-inches under my right pec. Looks pretty good though I take my shirt off all the time at pools. I did have some minor aches in the scar for a long time especially if I lifted heavy weights on a chest day. More of an annoyance that I noticed. I would do MVR if I were you.
Tom Elliott Hi Richard,
I had mitral and tricuspid repair done four years ago, with a full sternotomy. My surgeon ... Read more
Tom Elliott Hi Richard,
I had mitral and tricuspid repair done four years ago, with a full sternotomy. My surgeon said that because of the extent of the work he needed a little more room to work. I was inclined to give him what he wanted.
He also noted that because very little muscle is cut in going through the sternum it may actually be a less painful recovery. I have no basis for comparison, but I was back at work in 6 weeks, and except for coughing in the first week or two it really wasn't that bad. I took only over the counter pain meds at home. Not driving was a nuisance.
Good luck, whichever way you decide to go.
Liz Burroughs I had minimally invasive mitral valve repair surgery in 2015. I'm so glad that I was able to have tha ... Read more
Liz Burroughs I had minimally invasive mitral valve repair surgery in 2015. I'm so glad that I was able to have that kind of surgery! I only have a scar a little over 2 inches long on my upper right chest. I can hardly tell that it's there anymore! I didn't have any complications & I think that the recovery time is much less with this type of surgery. I would recommend this surgery to anyone who is a candidate for minimally invasive surgery.
Denise Kirchner Hi Richard. I had both. My first Mitral Valve Repair was a minimally invasive thorechotomy at Cleve ... Read more
Denise Kirchner Hi Richard. I had both. My first Mitral Valve Repair was a minimally invasive thorechotomy at Cleveland Clinic. In 2012. In 2026 I was back again for a Re-repair due to the gradual return of severe regurgitation over a four year period. Dr. Eric Roselli did both surgeries but the second was done through the sternum. My recovery was less painful with the sternotomy and I was not permitted to drive for 6 weeks after both surgeries. Everyone is different and handles pain differently; and every surgeon is different with the restrictions.
I wish you the best and will keep you in my prayers. God bless!
Adam Brown Richard, I had robotic MVR on Dec 14 and went back to work on Jan 4. From what I can tell, the pain a ... Read more
Adam Brown Richard, I had robotic MVR on Dec 14 and went back to work on Jan 4. From what I can tell, the pain and discomfort is probably the same the first week or so, but the the recovery is fast. 30 days after my surgery I felt so good, I decided I would do a light weight chest workout. Mistake. Set me back a few weeks with some mild/medium plurisy.
Like others have said, surgery is surger and to you’ll need to be patient.
In March I was told I can do whatever I want. In April, I did iFly and started mountain biking again - doing 15 mile, fast-paced rides now and feel great.
I would fully endorse robotic approach. My cardiologist was not keen on it, and the traditional (masters really) surgeons I saw made a strong case for open heart. But in the end, I am glad I went this route. My cardiologist says my “heart is function perfect”.
Steven Chilton I would focus more on finding the best doctor and see what he/she says. I hoped for a minimally inva ... Read more
Steven Chilton I would focus more on finding the best doctor and see what he/she says. I hoped for a minimally invasive until 2 top doctors told me they wouldn't do it because I had a stroke 9 years before and there is more stroke risk (esp. if you already had one). I had a "full sternotomy" though I only had a 5" incision. Like Bonnie, I had minimal pain and recovered quickly (I was in good shape to start) and have virtually no scar (maybe because they used glue instead of stitches) - the point being that each has its + and - and different people react differently to both and a good doctor and good hospital is key!